Is It Safe To Buy a Car With Venmo or Paypal?

Caleb Whittle

May 18, 2025

| Updated:

June 26, 2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the advantages of buying from a private seller vs car dealers?

Many people believe that buying a car from a dealer will save them money. Actually, going to a dealer is more expensive.

– Dealerships charge documentation fees above and beyond all the other taxes and fees you have to pay (the other taxes and fees are exactly the same whether you buy from a dealer or a private seller, by the way). Documentation fees can be as high as $995.
– Used vehicle dealerships usually have higher prices. Their business model is built around buying low and selling high to generate the spread that allows them to stay in business. To get the best deals, avoid the middleman and deal directly with private sellers.

When you buy a used car from a private seller on PrivateAuto, you avoid the doc fee and get a better deal.

We admit that buying from a dealer provides a level of convenience that is not typically available when buying from a private seller. That is, after all, why we exist. PrivateAuto gives you dealer-like convenience while also allowing you to transact with regular people like yourself.

Cutting out the middleman unlocks major savings. Our pioneering protections, like verified IDs and secure messaging, enable private sales with peace of mind. Buy directly from motivated sellers on your terms.

PrivateAuto is the best place to buy a car online from a private seller. We are the world’s only transactional automotive marketplace that provides the infrastructure and tools to transact securely. Other so-called “marketplaces” are actually just “meeting places”; they connect a buyer and a seller, but don’t support the transaction.

You can browse used cars for sale on PrivateAuto, but what if you don’t find the car you want? Maybe your perfect vehicle is listed on Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, or AutoTrader.

No problem. Find a car on another platform, then hop over to PrivateAuto to conclude the deal securely and quickly. Our DealNow fast-track solution gives you PrivateAuto’s seamless transaction support. Built-in tools like verified identities, legally binding documents, and lightning fast payments up to $1 million.

So if your dream car pops up somewhere else, no problem! Use DealNow to wrap up the deal conveniently and safely. PrivateAuto’s first-of-its-kind transactional tools enable smooth purchases regardless of where you discover the ideal set of wheels.

Many buyers prefer a cashier’s check for payment rather than cash.

A cashier’s check is more trustworthy than a personal check. However, unless you’re standing in front of the issuing bank during business hours and they verify the funds, the seller—if they’re smart—won’t see it as foolproof. Criminals have forged counterfeit cashier’s checks to con sellers.

To be absolutely sure your cashier’s check is valid, some sellers wait for it to clear their bank before releasing the title. This puts pressure on you to pay a large sum while trusting the seller to sign over the car later. It also means meeting twice, which is inconvenient.

PrivateAuto is safe, instantaneous, and guaranteed. With PrivateAuto Pay, funds instantly appear in the seller’s account, unlike a cashier’s check. The entire transaction can be concluded when you meet for a test drive.

While cashier’s checks are a step up from personal checks, they’re not all that great. For convenience and instant, guaranteed payments, use PrivateAuto Pay.

PrivateAuto has all the paperwork you need to buy a car in any stateEach state requires different paperwork to legally transfer titles and buy vehicles from a private party. Many states require a bill of sale. Some states have their own specific forms that are required to buy or sell a vehicle in the state.

PrivateAuto manages all these forms and makes them available for both buyers and sellers to electronically sign. The entire process is only accessible by the buyer and seller, which reduces the risk of identity theft. It can be difficult to keep up with state-specific laws, particularly if you’ve moved states recently, so use PrivateAuto to ensure a smooth and legal transaction.

If you’ve found a good used vehicle and are ready to buy it, a legitimate escrow service can help the transaction go smoothly. Unfortunately, escrow services are expensive and cumbersome.

PrivateAuto gives you escrow-like safeguards in the palm of your hand. Where escrow services charge exorbitant fees, PrivateAuto Pay is free.

Read how PrivateAuto Pay enables remote vehicle transactions to learn more about how it can replace escrow.

You can pay for a car via bank transfer if a seller is willing to give out their banking info. Many sellers will be uncomfortable exposing their sensitive financial information to strangers.

Aside from the risk, bank transfers are inconvenient, requiring some coordination. They also take time to clear, meaning you won’t be able to close the deal in one go.

Given these downsides, wire transfers are a suboptimal payment method, especially when you could be using PrivateAuto Pay.

PrivateAuto Pay enables instant, secure transfers without these issues. So you can conveniently and safely pay a private seller electronically in seconds, anytime 24/7.

Caleb Whittle

Contributing Author

Caleb Whittle is the Chief Marketing Officer at PrivateAuto. He’s based in Utah and has had a passion for education and learning throughout his life. Helping others understand the nuances of buying & selling cars has become his mission through content creation and writing. His current dream car is a Tesla Model S Plaid.